Official Feudalife CHALLENGE feedback Thread

cheerie132

Well-known member
Messages
971
Points
93
Why does it get screwed up at all thought with that "not enought credits" error? It worked just fine like 5 hours ago or so. Why does it work, then not work for a bit? Sure am glad I played it while it was still running okay, because I would have wasted my malus reduction for store purchase otherwise
 

ZODIAC

Member
Messages
42
Points
18
I got 2 Notice from King...today. I won one challenge and got notice, no key in Giveaway tab. Second time i got notice i didnt even won and i got malus for both times. :cry::cry:
And now i am getting Galacredits message again.
 
Last edited:

tugamix666

Well-known member
Messages
867
Points
93
Its on right now, if anyone lurking the forums wants to know.
Saw a lot of "Fetching user data" this time, so lots of page refreshing, might have been because lots of people were doing it at the same time so...

Why does it get screwed up at all thought with that "not enought credits" error? It worked just fine like 5 hours ago or so. Why does it work, then not work for a bit? Sure am glad I played it while it was still running okay, because I would have wasted my malus reduction for store purchase otherwise
This might be because the challenge gets turned off but the page to enter the challenge (https://www.indiegala.com/gameplay-giveaway) doesn't change to say its been turned off.
 

Yogzire

Member
Messages
52
Points
18
Hello,

I just completed the picking challenge where you should pick 40 saplings and I get an error message (king message) at the end instead of the winning message telling me I've just won a key. I checked my give aways key and I didn't receive any links or key as usual. But when playing again to the Massive giveaway I have the 4 points malus I did not have before playing. In this cae, do you know if there is a chance to get one key, even if not guaranteed key ?
 

Bill

New member
Messages
7
Points
3
Hello,

I just completed the picking challenge where you should pick 40 saplings and I get an error message (king message) at the end instead of the winning message telling me I've just won a key. I checked my give aways key and I didn't receive any links or key as usual. But when playing again to the Massive giveaway I have the 4 points malus I did not have before playing. In this cae, do you know if there is a chance to get one key, even if not guaranteed key ?

I got 2 Notice from King...today. I won one challenge and got notice, no key in Giveaway tab. Second time i got notice i didnt even won and i got malus for both times. :cry::cry:
And now i am getting Galacredits message again.

Same.
Two wins, two error messages, 0 keys, +8 seconds to malus. Have a nice day, developers. (y)
 

tugamix666

Well-known member
Messages
867
Points
93
I got 2 Notice from King...today. I won one challenge and got notice, no key in Giveaway tab. Second time i got notice i didnt even won and i got malus for both times. :cry::cry:
And now i am getting Galacredits message again.
Hello,

I just completed the picking challenge where you should pick 40 saplings and I get an error message (king message) at the end instead of the winning message telling me I've just won a key. I checked my give aways key and I didn't receive any links or key as usual. But when playing again to the Massive giveaway I have the 4 points malus I did not have before playing. In this cae, do you know if there is a chance to get one key, even if not guaranteed key ?
Same.
Two wins, two error messages, 0 keys, +8 seconds to malus. Have a nice day, developers. (y)
Good news: I had enough gala silver to play
Bad news: Out of four wins I got one notice from the king, one dupe and two dlc for some game I don't own...

XD

Did you see a "Fetching user data" message before the "Challenge" button shows? And did you play anyway or did you refresh the page?
I always refresh when I see it because I think it causes problems, I might be wrong though.
 
Messages
17
Points
3
Okay yeah, I'm a fair bit upset today. Four wins, with one invalid, one a dupe, and two for the same free game that I can't even give away. Am I just unnaturally unlucky or something? I'm really not great at these challenges and it's a huge disappointment to struggle through a challenge only to get no reward save for harder and unwinnable versions of the challenges. I just want to scream!

I get why they don't want to give out replacement keys anymore. It's easily abused to get extra keys and stuff. But what if they just gave a free malus reduction or some galasilver back? Course, that means the turnaround would have to be much faster than it could be with just the replacement keys, but maybe it could work as, like, reverse malus? I dunno. I'm just very upset, partly due to this frustration and partly due to an irl thing.
 

Zoliv

Well-known member
Messages
1,961
Points
113
Anyone winning with 16 malus?. I never tried, i think i could win on mining and archer challenge if i try, not sure. :)

I do that from time to time with a really good map on the hoeing challenge (like today). I'm sure i can do it on the watering challenge if i do absolutely no error, but it's not really in my challenges sequence that way.
 

tugamix666

Well-known member
Messages
867
Points
93
Okay yeah, I'm a fair bit upset today. Four wins, with one invalid, one a dupe, and two for the same free game that I can't even give away. Am I just unnaturally unlucky or something? I'm really not great at these challenges and it's a huge disappointment to struggle through a challenge only to get no reward save for harder and unwinnable versions of the challenges. I just want to scream!
Look at it positively, you won four times even though you think you're not great at the challenges, four wins is pretty good considering five is pretty much the limit with old account malus (you can get 6 if you start on hoeing but then you just get 4 the next day unless you go for an extra loop), so you're better than you think at these things.
Getting a dupe key always stings a little bit, or a lot if its for a good game you wanted, but yougot it for free so its not like you lost anything, its just annoying.

Anyone winning with 16 malus?. I never tried, i think i could win on mining and archer challenge if i try, not sure. :)
Winning MINING with 16 malus? Are you sure about that one? Archer is doable, just extra challenging, but when you win a 16 malus archer challenge... HMMMMMM thats a sweet victory!😁 At least for me, this is the only challenge that I Iike winning at the 16 malus limit probably because of the hard time I had getting used to it from the beggining, watering I think is also possible but that one is just "Yeah you gotta do it pixel perfect or you lose haha", but when it comes to "malus limit" challenges its really just play the one you WANT to beat at its possible limit because that will be the one that you'll enjoy beating the most.
I do that from time to time with a really good map on the hoeing challenge (like today). I'm sure i can do it on the watering challenge if i do absolutely no error, but it's not really in my challenges sequence that way.
Hoeing is also possible at 20 malus if you do it with no error, my notes say 4 missclick limit but that may also depend on getting a good map for it and I only tried it once or twice so I might be wrong... I should try this one again...
 

ZODIAC

Member
Messages
42
Points
18
Look at it positively, you won four times even though you think you're not great at the challenges, four wins is pretty good considering five is pretty much the limit with old account malus (you can get 6 if you start on hoeing but then you just get 4 the next day unless you go for an extra loop), so you're better than you think at these things.
Getting a dupe key always stings a little bit, or a lot if its for a good game you wanted, but yougot it for free so its not like you lost anything, its just annoying.


Winning MINING with 16 malus? Are you sure about that one? Archer is doable, just extra challenging, but when you win a 16 malus archer challenge... HMMMMMM thats a sweet victory!😁 At least for me, this is the only challenge that I Iike winning at the 16 malus limit probably because of the hard time I had getting used to it from the beggining, watering I think is also possible but that one is just "Yeah you gotta do it pixel perfect or you lose haha", but when it comes to "malus limit" challenges its really just play the one you WANT to beat at its possible limit because that will be the one that you'll enjoy beating the most.

Hoeing is also possible at 20 malus if you do it with no error, my notes say 4 missclick limit but that may also depend on getting a good map for it and I only tried it once or twice so I might be wrong... I should try this one again...
Yeah Archer i think the best option to make it on 16 malus, mining depends on map.
I do that from time to time with a really good map on the hoeing challenge (like today). I'm sure i can do it on the watering challenge if i do absolutely no error, but it's not really in my challenges sequence that way.
Yeah hoeing is also very nice with good map on high malus. Might try sometime, i lost almost all of my GS today because of all errors. :(
 

FreaKill

Well-known member
Messages
1,723
Points
113
Anyone winning with 16 malus?. I never tried, i think i could win on mining and archer challenge if i try, not sure. :)
Winning MINING with 16 malus? Are you sure about that one? Archer is doable, just extra challenging, but when you win a 16 malus archer challenge... HMMMMMM thats a sweet victory!
Yeah, I'm also not sure if mining in 44 seconds is possible at all.
I only win archers in 44 seconds if the last two spawn in the same gate or the last archer spawns in the bottom one, so I don't need to run as far to kill him. Had a real troll of an archers challenge today, where the first seven came out of the same gate - didn't win because the last two alternated the gates:cry:


I'm sure i can do it on the watering challenge if i do absolutely no error
Yeah it's possible, you even have time for one minor mistake at 44 seconds. You can even bring it down to 42 if you're absolutely perfect, but I only managed it a couple of times.


Hoeing is also possible at 20 malus if you do it with no error, my notes say 4 missclick limit but that may also depend on getting a good map for it and I only tried it once or twice so I might be wrong... I should try this one again...
Definitely try it! Precise manoeuvring in hoeing challenge was one of the the hardest to master for me, but it feels very rewarding to pull it off.
 

ZODIAC

Member
Messages
42
Points
18
Wait watering challenge with 16 malus is possible?. That sounds like a long shot, with mining i had good games but watering. :(
I must've been doing something wrong. :(
 

andrew smith

Well-known member
Messages
163
Points
63
The galacredits error is here to stay, it seems.
Chiming in on the 16 sec malus, I only OCCASIONALLY do it with a lucky fighting challenge. It ends up being my last of the 7 in a run through. I consistently get the weed puller (barring any RNG-37-black-weed tomfoolery, in which case I will go for the tree chopping), the hoeing, skip the trees and grass (impossible at full time, I swear), and then scrape up with mining and watering.
 

cheerie132

Well-known member
Messages
971
Points
93
This might be because the challenge gets turned off but the page to enter the challenge (https://www.indiegala.com/gameplay-giveaway) doesn't change to say its been turned off.
My thoughts exactly! I just remembered today that a while back I played a challenge and lost and when I clicked on play again I got the "not enought gala-something to enter" and was kicked out only to find out the challenge closed while I was playing the one that I failed. Good thinking, I guess this could be it.
Anyone winning with 16 malus?. I never tried, i think i could win on mining and archer challenge if i try, not sure. :)
If you win mining at 16 malus, PLEASE for the love of god take a screenshot, I'm ready to declare that one a modern day miracle :D seriously though, mining doesn't seem possible to me, but I have real trouble with the "click X times" challenges. But for me, watering plants is 90% success rate at 16 malus, managed to win it 2 or 3 times at 18 malus. Hoeing is defeinitely possible at 16, very often 18 and if you get lucky with the map 20 as well. Archers are a hit and miss for me, they seem waaay faster at shooting than they used to be for some reason. So sometimes I win at 16, sometimes I fail as low as 12 malus
 
Top