Official Feudalife CHALLENGE feedback Thread

[valike13]

Just expected the malus reduction calculations to show up still, just feels weird with it empty like that.

I was surprised too.

 

[gareppa]

Have you bought bundle and game in previous 24 hours, are you member of IG group on Steam and got positive feedback on giveaway? If yes, this is reason - all malus is reduced to 0.

uoa I did not think that was even possible

 

[tryyear]

Yes! (With right timing you may win up to 47 challenges )

wait so for example you make 3 giveaways and the feedbacks are all positive so the mulus gets reduce to zero or you also have to buy game or bundle

 

[tugamix666]

wait so for example you make 3 giveaways and the feedbacks are all positive so the mulus gets reduce to zero or you also have to buy game or bundle

No, the malus reductions don't stack with themselves, so even if you have 9 positive feedbacks on giveaways in a single day it'll still only give you a -2 malus reduction, but if you get all the reductions it gets down to 0 malus.

 

[Zoliv]

Got all malus reduction boosts today, along with 25 keys (only 2 dupes), strange to not see the calculation of the malus reduction, is it because it hit 0?

View attachment 2229
Click the image to enlarge it.

It is said in the challenge's description that the more you win keys, the more you have chances to hit AAA games (well """AAA""" games). Was it the case here ? Did you get unusual bigger games ?

 

[tugamix666]

It is said in the challenge's description that the more you win keys, the more you have chances to hit AAA games (well """AAA""" games). Was it the case here ? Did you get unusual bigger games ?

I think Disciples 3 and Zeno Clash 2 are the "bigger"ones, but there might be more that I'm missing, here's the full list:

Spoiler: Win List

Repeated wins:

1. A New Beginning Retail
2. Cargo! - Retail (BitComposer)
3. Commandos: Behind Enemy Lines
4. Dementium 2
5. Disciples III: Reincarnation
6. Gravi Retail Key
7. Hexcells Plus
8. Ion Assault Comp
9. inMomentum Retail
10. M.U.D. TV Retail
11. Magicka DLC: The Stars are Left
12. Mind: Path to Thalamus
13. Mountain
14. POSTAL 1 Retail
15. Red Johnson's Chronicles - 1+2 - Steam Special Edition
16. Shadows: Price For Our Sins Steam Store and Retail Key
17. The God's Chain
18. Truck Racer
19. Turba Comp
20. Windforge
21. Zeno Clash 2 Special Edition Retail

First time wins:

1. Alien Hallway Retail
2. Crazy Machines Elements - Collision Course and Mental Activity DLC

Duplicates:

1. Loren the Amazon Princess - Deluxe Version
2. The Chaos Engine

 

[Narga95]

I think Disciples 3 and Zeno Clash 2 are the "bigger"ones, but there might be more that I'm missing, here's the full list:

Zeno Clash 2 it's definitely not one of the bigger ones, I am full of them and so are other people, but I'm pretty sure that it's not super common either.

It is said in the challenge's description that the more you win keys, the more you have chances to hit AAA games (well """AAA""" games). Was it the case here ? Did you get unusual bigger games ?

The thing about winning more = the better games you get it's because once the bundles were divided in more tiers (T1, T2, T3, like Humble Bundle for examples) in which T1 games were often bundled a lot while in T2 less and in T3 were either popular indie games or very rarely bundled games. But those are tiers are a thing of the past I'm pretty sure, and a once T3 game that can be hard to get it's in fact a really cheap game, like for example if a bundle consisted of a T1 and T2 of magicka dlcs then the T3 would have magicka there and that would make it rare but cheap.

Let's check a 3 years old bundle, the Daedalic Entertainment Bundle, we will see that Deponia that's a really cheap game that everyone has it's a T2 game, that's why it's pretty hard to find but still common enough that most people who played a lot have found once or twice, while games like Crash Time III and Anna's quest are found very rarely.
In short, better tiers don't mean much.

 

[tugamix666]

Got all malus reduction boosts today, along with 25 keys (only 2 dupes)

Got 24 keys today, and only 2 3 were duplicates (3 now that Flatout turned out to be a duplicate), and yeah seems like Zeno Clash 2 isn't as rare as I thought.
And if anyone is interest in checking the wins (this time numbered from first win to last) here's the list:

Spoiler: Win List

First time wins:

1- Type Rider Steam Store and Retail Key​

Repeated wins:

2- Sacred Gold Comp​

3- Kalaban​

5- Zeno Clash 2 Special Edition Retail​

6- Zeno Clash 2 Special Edition Retail​

7- Air Conflicts: Secret War​

10- Really Big Sky Retail​

11- Altitude_Retail​

12- Lionheart - King's Crusade Comp​

13- Finding Teddy​

14- TRAUMA​

15- Quell Memento​

16- Primal Carnage​

17- Commandos 2: Men of Courage​

18- Bad Rats Comp​

19- Nordic D (Indiegala) Guerrila/Armageddon​

20- Men of War: Red Tide Comp​

21- Sacraboar​

22- KAMI​

23- Pacific Storm​

24- Eidolon​

Duplicates:

4- Speedball 2 HD​

8- Flatout Retail​

9- The Chaos Engine​

 

[tryyear]

Got 24 keys today, and only 2 were duplicates again (although Flatout is likely also duplicated looking at the duplicates thread, if anyone wants to try it, just ask), and yeah seems like Zeno Clash 2 isn't as rare as I thought.
And if anyone is interest in checking the wins (this time numbered from first win to last) here's the list:

Spoiler: Win List

First time wins:

1- Type Rider Steam Store and Retail Key​

Repeated wins:

2- Sacred Gold Comp​

3- Kalaban​

5- Zeno Clash 2 Special Edition Retail​

6- Zeno Clash 2 Special Edition Retail​

7- Air Conflicts: Secret War​

8- Flatout Retail​

10- Really Big Sky Retail​

11- Altitude_Retail​

12- Lionheart - King's Crusade Comp​

13- Finding Teddy​

14- TRAUMA​

15- Quell Memento​

16- Primal Carnage​

17- Commandos 2: Men of Courage​

18- Bad Rats Comp​

19- Nordic D (Indiegala) Guerrila/Armageddon​

20- Men of War: Red Tide Comp​

21- Sacraboar​

22- KAMI​

23- Pacific Storm​

24- Eidolon​

Duplicates:

4- Speedball 2 HD​

9- The Chaos Engine​

can i try flatout
edit:tq for the key, its a dupe

 

[tugamix666]

Finally managed to get 10/8 trees with no malus, been trying this for a while now and always got 9/8 and either really close to finishing the last tree or just 7/8 out of 15 strikes.

Spoiler: 10 Trees

View attachment 1618

Pretty good.

It's been a while since I first done this, and now I have done this 10 times, getting it twice each day with the full malus reduction of the last 2 days.


Click the images to enlarge them.

Is there something you always try to do in a particular challenge that feels better than getting a win?

 

[tryyear]

It's been a while since I first done this, and now I have done this 10 times, getting it twice each day with the full malus reduction of the last 2 days.

View attachment 2244View attachment 2245View attachment 2246View attachment 2247
Click the images to enlarge them.

Is there something you always try to do in a particular challenge that feels better than getting a win?

getting 0.04 gala credit for a challenge(quite rare)

 

[Zoliv]

Is there something you always try to do in a particular challenge that feels better than getting a win?

Trying to get 42/40 at the roots challenge. You have to make absolutely 0 error (at least with my rig). Or managing to win the sickling challenge at -12s (closest i got was 58/60).

 

[BurningPixels]

Got 24 keys today, and only 2 3 were duplicates (3 now that Flatout turned out to be a duplicate), and yeah seems like Zeno Clash 2 isn't as rare as I thought.
And if anyone is interest in checking the wins (this time numbered from first win to last) here's the list:

I checked Zeno Clash 2 I won it 5 times from last march.

 

[Zoliv]

I checked Zeno Clash 2 I won it 5 times from last march.

10 times for me this year (+ the one that went on my account).

 

[War Pig]

The fighting challenge seems to be bugged. The sword keeps disappearing after about 10 seconds of play. It used to happen infrequently, but lately it's been every time I play.

 

[街溜子]

Got 24 keys today, and only 2 3 were duplicates (3 now that Flatout turned out to be a duplicate), and yeah seems like Zeno Clash 2 isn't as rare as I thought.
And if anyone is interest in checking the wins (this time numbered from first win to last) here's the list:

Spoiler: Win List

First time wins:

1- Type Rider Steam Store and Retail Key​

Repeated wins:

2- Sacred Gold Comp​

3- Kalaban​

5- Zeno Clash 2 Special Edition Retail​

6- Zeno Clash 2 Special Edition Retail​

7- Air Conflicts: Secret War​

10- Really Big Sky Retail​

11- Altitude_Retail​

12- Lionheart - King's Crusade Comp​

13- Finding Teddy​

14- TRAUMA​

15- Quell Memento​

16- Primal Carnage​

17- Commandos 2: Men of Courage​

18- Bad Rats Comp​

19- Nordic D (Indiegala) Guerrila/Armageddon​

20- Men of War: Red Tide Comp​

21- Sacraboar​

22- KAMI​

23- Pacific Storm​

24- Eidolon​

Duplicates:

4- Speedball 2 HD​

8- Flatout Retail​

9- The Chaos Engine​

???
Hold on, How is it possible to win 24 keys in under 24 hours?
I only win (4) at most a day with 7 malus. Even with purchases I win 5-6...
And you win with the same account right? Please explain this magic!

I only know very long ago you could win 20+ keys per day with no malus

 

[tryyear]

???
Hold on, How is it possible to win 24 keys in under 24 hours?
I only win (4) at most a day with 7 malus. Even with purchases I win 5-6...
And you win with the same account right? Please explain this magic!

I only know very long ago you could win 20+ keys per day with no malus

i think it was basically....buy bundle and game,2 mulus each,be a member of indiegala steam group(1mulus),positive feedback from giveaway(2mulus)....it has to happen at the same time

 

[Chii-chan]

closed for two days now (at the times available for me)... anyone know open times?

 

[tugamix666]

Hold on, How is it possible to win 24 keys in under 24 hours?

If you get all the malus reduction boosts then you get 0 malus, and with 240 GalaSilver thats 24 plays with 0 malus which are pretty much guaranteed wins. + Then you can also play when the silver recharges for more.

 

[街溜子]

If you get all the malus reduction boosts then you get 0 malus, and with 240 GalaSilver thats 24 plays with 0 malus which are pretty much guaranteed wins. + Then you can also play when the silver recharges for more.

Okay, what are malus reduction "boosts"?

i think it was basically....buy bundle and game,2 mulus each,be a member of indiegala steam group(1mulus),positive feedback from giveaway(2mulus)....it has to happen at the same time

Bundle + game? Like a game and a bundle from indiegala?

closed for two days now (at the times available for me)... anyone know open times?

I know at 8 am my time the challenge resets (midnight for Europe), and you wrote that at 7:40 am... , which means challenge will reset in 20 minutes hence your chances of being able to play are very low.

I don't know what your region is, it bugs me a lot too since I only play from 6 am-8 am most days before I go to work. I think best time is after 7-8 hours when most people in the West wake up then you would have higher chances of it being open. (Although some times they are closed 24 hours/day, but it is very rare)