Report Giveaways Here

Fractard

Active member
Messages
269
Points
43
I never understood why they never tied it to Steam Accounts completely. It should be a requirement, not a recommendation.
Also if they locked it to particular steam levels or those that have access to the marketplace, it would cut down on a lot of fake accounts.
You'd be surprised how many people don't want to fork over $5 to unlock the marketplace.
Like I have 5 (or more) Steam accounts of the same guy on my Steam blacklist, all lvl 0 with only CSGO and all VAC ban. This is not new, I check my GA and I started in 2017.
I remember discovering the no free game rule afterward by broswing on the forum and some other people too. This site GAs have always been a jungle with little do to stop cheater.

NB: some Anna's Quest GAs are still glitched, its like 5€ on Steam but 103IS here instead of 15IS.
 
Messages
19
Points
13
Hi there, I think it depends on the positive to negative ratio and I always hope even if people posted "duplicate keys" that it was an accident. I can say that for the two negative reviews I've got that the users sadly did not get in touch with me, I'm 100% sure we could've found a solution (possibly can even now). But I don't know if they even would be interested to be 'bothered' by me to get my "100 percent positive rating". Then there's this 'ongoing trend' some indie developers on Steam started, in which the developer revoked originally good keys through steam which of course caused trouble with the giveaways.
We're human, mistakes happen, misunderstandings are a possibility, so I guess one should always try to get into contact with the person who created the giveaway. So uh thanks for reading my train of thought?

Best greetings,
Ossel

Hi Osselpi, and thank you for your answer.
My question was however made to the admins and other staff of IG. I've been a member for a few years now, lvl 6, sinned in the first 2 levels here making a few GA's that were masses, but that was a very long time ago.
And that was why I asked the admins, why is it suddenly OK to get to lvl 6 and above by posting "crap".

Thanks, Ossel, have a nice day :)

I miss mseals, I hope he/she is ok, I didn't know about any surgery.
 
Messages
19
Points
13
Like I have 5 (or more) Steam accounts of the same guy on my Steam blacklist, all lvl 0 with only CSGO and all VAC ban. This is not new, I check my GA and I started in 2017.
I remember discovering the no free game rule afterward by broswing on the forum and some other people too. This site GAs have always been a jungle with little do to stop cheater.

NB: some Anna's Quest GAs are still glitched, its like 5€ on Steam but 103IS here instead of 15IS.

But they could tie it to a Steam account lvl 1 or higher, since to level up from 0 to 1 will cost money. Not very profitable for a bot owner or clone maker to pay $5 for each account to be able to scam, I guess.
 
Messages
19
Points
13
*snip*

P.S. Can someone tell me how to check reputation and Steam profile for giveaway creator if this person isn't one of winners for my giveaway and he's not active in trade section? I can't see it from the giveaway page - their name is linked to forum profile (why - I wonder).
[/QUOTE]

Oh, I can't even find my OWN level or stats or when I joined :( Other than it says I joined the forums just a year ago, which is not true.
Let me know if you ever find out how to, ehmm, find out these thingies ;)
 

Fractard

Active member
Messages
269
Points
43
P.S. Can someone tell me how to check reputation and Steam profile for giveaway creator if this person isn't one of winners for my giveaway and he's not active in trade section? I can't see it from the giveaway page - their name is linked to forum profile (why - I wonder)
You check Indiegala profile for giveaways feedback on the site but you have either to find the profile url (if he write it somewhere) or find one of his giveaways.

RISK: Global Domination - European Conquest was free on Steelseries:
 

cheerie132

Well-known member
Messages
971
Points
93
agreed, but maybe it's a legit key since that game used to be NOT be free (it's free since like last October 2019 or something?). so until the giveaway end this person gets the benefit of the doubt, maybe they bought the key a long time ago in which case it will at least give the winner trading cards on Steam which is neat since the free version does not do that. We'll have to wait for someone to win the key and report to us if it was a good one or a fake.
 

Таня Дюк

New member
Messages
14
Points
3
hi ive won a giveaway for Annas quest: Link
sadly the key didnt work... and i read somewhere this person also gave away a faulty key for the night of the rabbit
both giveaways cost 103 IC to enter... and would have given a lot of points towards leveling.
i also tried to contact the gifter but to no avail

feels really bad as i was looking forward towards this game
 

WizardStan

Well-known member
Messages
363
Points
63
hi ive won a giveaway for Annas quest: Link
sadly the key didnt work... and i read somewhere this person also gave away a faulty key for the night of the rabbit
both giveaways cost 103 IC to enter... and would have given a lot of points towards leveling.
i also tried to contact the gifter but to no avail

feels really bad as i was looking forward towards this game
Just give them negative feedback. That way they don't get the points and eventually, if they keep doing it, the automod will autoban them, assuming it actually works as I thought it did. Given I saw someone with a 3/-14 ratio still posting fake keys I'm starting to doubt.
 

Zeph4Sure

Active member
Messages
75
Points
33

Minipimer

New member
Messages
10
Points
3
Hi there. Maybe it's not the best thread to ask for, but could someone direct me to a official thread with the rules for giveaways? There was a link on the first page of this thread but it redirected to a 404, and I don't seem to be able to find any pinned message anywhere (which seems strange).

Thanks in advance, and apologies if this should be requested somewhere else, but it seemed a good place to start by.

Edit: found some links in the previous page about more or less how it should work. It seems thera is no official set-in-stone rules, so I will try to apply common sense. Thanks!
 
Last edited:

GrayAmuletStars

Well-known member
Messages
559
Points
63
Hi there. Maybe it's not the best thread to ask for, but could someone direct me to a official thread with the rules for giveaways? There was a link on the first page of this thread but it redirected to a 404, and I don't seem to be able to find any pinned message anywhere (which seems strange).

Thanks in advance, and apologies if this should be requested somewhere else, but it seemed a good place to start by.

Edit: found some links in the previous page about more or less how it should work. It seems thera is no official set-in-stone rules, so I will try to apply common sense. Thanks!

Hi Minipimer74, thanks for asking. The most official rules you could find are these I guess:

Although the forum suggests that there have been more rules which previously were enforced but might not be "supverised and enforced" right now. These can be found here:
 

cheerie132

Well-known member
Messages
971
Points
93
Nope, even if the key is legit we shouldn't be able to post free games.

but if the key is legit, then the key is NOT for a free game in my opinion. it's for a PAID VERSION of a game that is now free. Like the free game is a different "package" than the one that this user was giving away, at least for me. I would't mind winning a key for a game if it gave me card drops. at all
 

syleox

Well-known member
Messages
3,593
Points
113
but, by definition, a giveaway is a mean to offer something which cost money...so giving away a free game is not a proper giveaway
 
Top