Official Feudalife CHALLENGE feedback Thread

[HoangMarcel]

I won 4 keys and 3 inconsistent data messages today. I spent 100 galasilver to reduce 2 malus seconds but after 1 round (I didn't win btw) the 2 malus seconds is still there and 100 galasilver I spent is gone.

 

[RiciRickMOD]

2 games in a row lost with 15 malus despite actually reaching the goal with several seconds to spare.
Third game resulted in "Inconsistent data"
View attachment 174

Is plant-watering the only game currently in rotation? (It was the only game I was faced with yesterday, and the same seems to be the case now.)

Edit: New round (still plant-watering), and yet another instance of "Inconsistent Data Detected!".
Plants watered: 16, with 4 seconds left on the clock. The final plant finished growing with 2 seconds left on the clock. In the meantime, I had watered a 17th plant 3 times before the time completely ran out. Gonna give it one more attempt. If it still gives the same results, I'll call it for this round and deem it completely broken for the time being.

Hi.

Interesting.
It would be useful to understand:
- how many ( real ) secs you took to beat the challenge ( even approximately ).
- the time limit with malus ( should be 45 secs, right) ?
- if you ALWAYS have a broken challenge rotation? ( By design you should always face a different challenge, never twice the same ).

Do you have any script blocker or additional script running? We found out strange behaviors with some conflicting scripts.

Thank you again. Your feedback is very, very useful.

 

[RiciRickMOD]

I won 4 keys and 3 inconsistent data messages today. I spent 100 galasilver to reduce 2 malus seconds but after 1 round (I didn't win btw) the 2 malus seconds is still there and 100 galasilver I spent is gone.

That is correct.
You remove malus only for that playthrough.

 

[TTRM]

Hi.

Interesting.
It would be useful to understand:
- how many ( real ) secs you took to beat the challenge ( even approximately ).
- the time limit with malus ( should be 45 secs, right) ?
- if you ALWAYS have a broken challenge rotation? ( By design you should always face a different challenge, never twice the same ).

Do you have any script blocker or additional script running? We found out strange behaviors with some conflicting scripts.

Thank you again. Your feedback is very, very useful.

Further edits to my post has been made since you quoted it.
Gonna try one more round, now that it seems to be rotating the challenges the way it should.

Weed Whacking (sickle challenge) might need some tweaking too.
Flawless performance left me with 50/60, with no mis-clicks. (15 malus)

It takes a little less than a full second to clear each weed, but the action isn't fast enough to counter the 15-second penalty.

Edit:
Mining: completed
Result: Inconsidtent data once more.

As you can see from the image, I'm well on my way to mining a 13th rock, which means this was not a photo-finish performance.

Interesting.
It would be useful to understand:
- how many ( real ) secs you took to beat the challenge ( even approximately ).
- the time limit with malus ( should be 45 secs, right) ?
- if you ALWAYS have a broken challenge rotation? ( By design you should always face a different challenge, never twice the same ).

Do you have any script blocker or additional script running? We found out strange behaviors with some conflicting scripts.

-I don't have any practical way to start/stop a stopwatch while playing the challenges.
-The time is indeed 45 seconds. Nothing wrong there.
- The rotation seem to have fixed itself at this point. (It gave me 5 consecutive rounds of watering yesterday, as well as an additional 3 rounds today.)

No additional scripts running. I do use NoScript (Firefox), but this shouldn't cause any issues. I tweaked it to allow the scripts required to play the challenges the first time around and have made no alterations since then. With those settings, the challenge was successfully completed every time (depending on my own performance, of course).
Since I did successfully receive my keys from yesterday's rounds, there should be no need to tweak my settings in NoScript.
But just in case it did cause some unintended results, I did disable it completely prior to continuing with the additional rounds I just now played. The results were the same.

Today's results
Challenges played: 10
Challenges genuinely lost: 5 (1 watering, 1 archer, 1 sickle, 1 hoe, 1 sappling)
Challenges won, but with "inconsistent data" being the result: 5 (3 watering, 1 woodcutting, 1 mining)
Keys received: 0/5 (due to "inconsistent data")

I'm considering filing a support ticket in order to claim these 5 keys (after all, I did "pay" for them ;p ), but I'll hold off for now and wait for your reply on the matter.
For the time being, I'm abandoning the challenge. There's no point in playing if this "inconsistent data"-error persists on every win.

 

[uluqulu gamehag.com]

If i have 15s Malus and use my maximum 200 silver to remove 4 seconds and i got 11s Malus. How to remove more seconds?
"You can lower your malus by waiting...." how long and how many?

 

[ASAC_Nobody]

If i have 15s Malus and use my maximum 200 silver to remove 4 seconds and i got 11s Malus. How to remove more seconds?
"You can lower your malus by waiting...." how long and how many?

You earn 10 Indiegala Silver per hour. You could also convert Indiegala Credit to Silver to speed things up.

 

[RiciRickMOD]

Further edits to my post has been made since you quoted it.
Gonna try one more round, now that it seems to be rotating the challenges the way it should.

Weed Whacking (sickle challenge) might need some tweaking too.
Flawless performance left me with 50/60, with no mis-clicks. (15 malus)
View attachment 175
It takes a little less than a full second to clear each weed, but the action isn't fast enough to counter the 15-second penalty.

Edit:
Mining: completed
Result: Inconsidtent data once more.
View attachment 176
As you can see from the image, I'm well on my way to mining a 13th rock, which means this was not a photo-finish performance.



-I don't have any practical way to start/stop a stopwatch while playing the challenges.
-The time is indeed 45 seconds. Nothing wrong there.
- The rotation seem to have fixed itself at this point. (It gave me 5 consecutive rounds of watering yesterday, as well as an additional 3 rounds today.)

No additional scripts running. I do use NoScript (Firefox), but this shouldn't cause any issues. I tweaked it to allow the scripts required to play the challenges the first time around and have made no alterations since then. With those settings, the challenge was successfully completed every time (depending on my own performance, of course).
Since I did successfully receive my keys from yesterday's rounds, there should be no need to tweak my settings in NoScript.
But just in case it did cause some unintended results, I did disable it completely prior to continuing with the additional rounds I just now played. The results were the same.

Today's results
Challenges played: 10
Challenges genuinely lost: 5 (1 watering, 1 archer, 1 sickle, 1 hoe, 1 sappling)
Challenges won, but with "inconsistent data" being the result: 5 (3 watering, 1 woodcutting, 1 mining)
Keys received: 0/5 (due to "inconsistent data")

I'm considering filing a support ticket in order to claim these 5 keys (after all, I did "pay" for them ;p ), but I'll hold off for now and wait for your reply on the matter.
For the time being, I'm abandoning the challenge. There's no point in playing if this "inconsistent data"-error persists on every win.

The challenges are still in 'beta'/test phase.

We absolutely cannot offer support if you play with NoScript or other script blocker/tweakers because some crucial parts of the game are heavily based on scripts.
Using a script blocker even partially may led to ( as the message says ) 'inconsistent results'.
Besides, in some particular cases using a script blocker can even been considered malicious behavior and seen as cheating from server software and there is a risk that server bans your profile.
That is why we say in the info page to not use it on feudalife page.


Our recommendation is to play with no script blocker at all, and possibly on Chrome.

 

[uluqulu gamehag.com]

Our recommendation is to play with no script blocker at all, and possibly on Chrome.

I finish challange on chrome without any browser plugin enable with 15s Malus.
Error message:

 

[GrayLandsFantastic]

I am playing with clean chrome browser too, and get "inconsistent data" error every time I manage to beat the challenge, never got it when i fail.

 

[RiciRickMOD]

This is a visual bug. server side data shows correctly ( 8/9 in your case ).

we are uploading a new version right now that should fix the visual bug.

 

[Ratha]

Completed this about 20 minutes ago Playing in Chrome with adblock plus completely disabled across all of IndieGala. 12 second malus, and error:

 

[TTRM]

We absolutely cannot offer support if you play with NoScript or other script blocker/tweakers because some crucial parts of the game are heavily based on scripts.
Using a script blocker even partially may led to ( as the message says ) 'inconsistent results'.
Besides, in some particular cases using a script blocker can even been considered malicious behavior and seen as cheating from server software and there is a risk that server bans your profile.
That is why we say in the info page to not use it on feudalife page.

Our recommendation is to play with no script blocker at all, and possibly on Chrome.

My main reason for using NoScript is to prevent any instances of potentially malicious scripts from running on my system. I have no suspicions that any of the IG-pages contain anything malicious, but any site is subject to the same possibility of being hacked from outside sources and having malicous content injected into their code. By using NoScript, I'm adding an extra level of security on my end.
Unless you applied some additional scripts with this update, there's no reason for NoScript to be the cause of this issue, nor Firefox over Chrome for that matter.
Additionally, it is evident by other user-reports that the error occurs regardless of which browser and both with and without add-ons.
I have played both with and without add-ons active, but the results still stay the same.

 

[RiciRickMOD]

I finish challange on chrome without any browser plugin enable with 15s Malus.
Error message:
View attachment 177

Hi.

This screen is from a challenge you played yesterday.
( you play archers challenges twice, 1 won, 1 lost ).

In the challenge you lost you got 9/9 due to visual bug ( now fixed ) but the real data recorded by server is 8/9

 

[Nicholas Szergey Cage]

I always get Inconsidtent data

 

[RiciRickMOD]

My main reason for using NoScript is to prevent any instances of potentially malicious scripts from running on my system. I have no suspicions that any of the IG-pages contain anything malicious, but any site is subject to the same possibility of being hacked from outside sources and having malicous content injected into their code. By using NoScript, I'm adding an extra level of security on my end.
Unless you applied some additional scripts with this update, there's no reason for NoScript to be the cause of this issue, nor Firefox over Chrome for that matter.
Additionally, it is evident by other user-reports that the error occurs regardless of which browser and both with and without add-ons.
I have played both with and without add-ons active, but the results still stay the same.

As i said in previous post we cannot offer debug / support for match played using script blockers. Not until challenges exit beta phase.
That said, this is the log of all the challenges played by you today.
You playd all challenges with 15 secs handicap ( max time for the match 45 secs ) and according the performance results that the server recorded
in your matches you ( correctly ) did not win any challenge.
For example in challenge 1 ( sickling ) you scored 49/60
in challenge 0 ( chopping ) you scored 7/8
in challenge 6 ( Hoeing ) you scored 53 out of 56
in challenge 5 ( Picking ) you scored 32 out of 36 ... and so on


the fact that you saw a wrong display info like 12/12 like
AquaGarbSorcerer reported
or even an higher number like
Ratha Wynter
just posted is due to a visual bug that ( hopefully ) we should have just fixed thanks to your help guys!

Let's match again and see if it is still present.

 

[RiciRickMOD]

I always get Inconsidtent data

Hi Tokisaki!
According our logs you did not play any challenge today.


We did many fixes uploading over 10 new patches since yesterday, the last one 5 minutes ago.
Please try now and you should not experience that error.

 

[GrayLandsFantastic]

Just completed mining challenge, and got error again. I was at 12/12 completed rocks, and 6 out of 7 "clicks" to complete next one.

 

[RiciRickMOD]

Completed this about 20 minutes ago Playing in Chrome with adblock plus completely disabled across all of IndieGala. 12 second malus, and error:

View attachment 178

Hi!

according our logs you just played 1 match today with the account you are writing from.
and it was the sickling Challenge, not Mining.

Please, let us know if you used another account, and , in case, which one so we can offer more help.

Best!

 

[TTRM]

That said, this is the log of all the challenges played by you today.
View attachment 180

Seems 3 entries are missing from this list, as I played 10 rounds today. (started with 200 silver, ended with 100 silver)
Is there a chance that the error might cause the "successful" attempts not to be logged?

Hi Tokisaki!
According our logs you did not play any challenge today.

View attachment 182
We did many fixes uploading over 10 new patches since yesterday, the last one 5 minutes ago.
Please try now and you should not experience that error.

 

[RiciRickMOD]

Seems 3 entries are missing from this list, as I played 10 rounds today. (started with 200 silver, ended with 100 silver)
Is there a chance that the error might cause the "successful" attempts not to be logged?

Entries are recorded only if you complete the match ( if you abandon the match even at lasts econd we do not record it )